Our Values Don't Align as a Couple… Does That Mean We're Not Compatible?
“Our values just don’t align anymore.” We hear it from couples all the time, usually followed by the question underneath it: does that mean we’re not compatible?
In Episode 60 of the Save My Marriage Podcast, we unpack why that belief is often built on a misunderstanding. We share the questions we use with couples to uncover what they actually value in this season of life, why so many people say family comes first while their calendar tells a different story, and how to turn the most common values clash we see, achievement versus connection, into something that helps you both.
We also share our own story. For years, Adam resisted family holidays because business growth was his top priority. What changed wasn’t Adam giving up his values. It was noticing that time with the family made the business better.
1. You’ve Confused Alignment With Being the Same
A lot of people hear the word aligned and assume it means liking the same things, at the same time, in the same way. That isn’t alignment. That’s an expectation of perfection, and no two people will ever meet it.
Healthy couples share some values, but even shared values can look completely different in practice. Aston’s highest value has long been growth, which for her meant courses, books and learning. Adam’s version of growth showed up as travel and new experiences. Neither was wrong. And because Aston stayed open to Adam’s expression of it, travel became one of her biggest sources of growth too.
The order of your values can differ as well. One of you might rank family first and business third. The other might rank them the opposite way. That’s a difference in hierarchy, not proof you’re incompatible.
Practice: Write down one value you and your partner share but express differently. Describe what it looks like for each of you, without deciding whose version is better.
2. Stop Running a Win Lose Marriage
The real damage usually comes from beliefs like these:
- If you really loved me, you’d value what I value
- If our marriage mattered to you, you’d prioritise what I prioritise
- If you cared, you’d want me to have what I want
None of that is partnership. It’s projecting your values onto your partner and expecting them to be happy about it. Everyone wants to live in line with their own values, so this approach creates resistance, resentment and a sense of shrinking yourself to keep the peace.
Think about a workplace. A boss who only says “here’s what I need from you” rarely gets anyone’s best. The best leaders ask what matters to their team, then show how the work helps them get it. Marriage works the same way.
Checklist: signs you’re stuck in win lose
- You treat your partner’s priorities as wrong rather than different
- Big decisions turn into a contest over whose value wins
- You feel offended when your partner’s top value isn’t the same as yours
- You try to convince your partner to want what you want
3. Find Out What You Actually Value
Ask most people for their highest values and you’ll hear family, marriage, health or financial security. Then look at their calendar. Someone working 50 or 60 hours a week who calls family their number one priority usually isn’t living that way.
There’s no shame in that. Adam openly says that in this season, work ranks above family for him. He loves his wife and kids deeply, and family is still in his top three. It’s just not first right now. But you can’t make good decisions if you’re lying to yourself about where you are.
We’re also not talking about the values society tells you to have. We mean the ones that come from within you, the things you’d pursue even when you’re tired or sick. Values also shift with each season of life, and that’s normal.
Practice: Look at your last month of time and spending. Write down the three areas that got most of your discretionary hours and money. Those are clues to your real values.
4. Ask How Your Values Can Benefit Each Other
The most common clash we see is one partner valuing achievement, business and freedom while the other values family, connection and shared experiences. It gets framed as business versus family, and both people dig in.
Instead of asking whose value wins, ask three better questions:
- What is the need for me?
- What is the need for my partner?
- How could what matters to you support what matters to me?
Here’s how that played out for us. Adam used to push back on holidays because they felt like time away from building the business. Over time, he noticed that every stretch of real family time, a week or even a month away, brought back energy and fresh ideas that made the business and investing better. Family connection wasn’t competing with his goals. It was fuelling them. And a thriving business is what funds the family holidays Aston values.
If you’re struggling to see the benefits, start by finding three. Then push for five, ten, even twenty. Most couples only ever count the cost of their differences, never what those differences make possible.
Practice: List one value of yours and one of your partner’s that feel like they compete. Write down three ways each one could support the other.
5. Use This Lens for Every Big Decision
This isn’t only a conversation for when you feel disconnected. We used the same approach when we had different views on having another baby. It took time, but we got there by looking for the win win rather than trying to win.
It works for moving house, moving country, starting a business or changing careers. If you want to expand and your partner values security, your plan may feel threatening to them. Telling them to want what you want won’t work. Showing them how your plan protects or even strengthens their security will.
And remember, difference is part of why you were attracted to each other. Your partner brings out things in you that you’d never find alone. Couples who are exactly the same often get bored.
Checklist: before your next big decision
- We’ve each said what we value most in this season
- We’ve named what each of us needs from this decision
- We’ve listed how the decision could serve both our values
- Nobody is being asked to simply give up what matters to them
Worksheet: Discover Your Values in This Season
Answer each question on your own first. Then sit down with your partner, share your answers first, and ask them the same questions one at a time. Don’t just ask “what are your values?” Most people will say they don’t know.
Part 1: Answer the questions
- Where does your time naturally go when nothing needs to be done?
- Imagining your necessities are covered, where does your money go, or where would you like it to go?
- Outside of logistics, what do you think about most?
- What do you love talking about, with anyone from friends to the person at the checkout?
- What do you research when nobody has asked you to?
- What are you naturally disciplined and consistent around?
- What do you always find energy for, even when you’re tired or sick?
- What goals do you keep coming back to?
Part 2: Find the themes
Go back through your answers and highlight anything that repeats. Your top three themes are likely your top three values in this season.
|
|
Me |
My partner |
|---|---|---|
|
Value 1 |
|
|
|
Value 2 |
|
|
|
Value 3 |
|
|
Part 3: Talk it through
- Are we spending our time, money and energy in line with these values right now?
- Where are we already aligned?
- Where do our values seem to compete?
- How could each of our values support the other? Find at least three benefits for each.
Revisit this every six to twelve months, because your values will shift as your life does.
FAQ
Can a marriage work if our values are different? Yes. Most couples share some values and differ on others. What matters is whether you treat those differences as competition or look for how they support each other.
What if my partner ranks work above family? Start with curiosity instead of offence. Ask what that value gives them and how it might serve the family. Then talk about the systems that make sure the family’s needs are still met, like weekly dates and regular check ins.
How do I find my real values? Look at evidence rather than ideals. Where your spare time, money, attention and energy go reveals more than what you think you should value. The worksheet above walks you through it.
Do values change over time? Yes. Values shift with each season of life. That’s why we encourage couples to revisit their values and their shared vision every six to twelve months.
What if our difference is a genuine dealbreaker? Some differences, like whether to have children, can’t simply be reframed. They deserve an honest conversation, and often support from a coach or counsellor, rather than pressure for one person to give in.
My partner won’t do this exercise. What now? Go first. Answer the questions yourself and share your answers before asking theirs. Asking one question at a time makes it far easier for them to open up.
Resources and Next Steps
- Recreate Your Relationship Online (RYRO) — a three part video series covering communication, connection, and intimacy. The perfect starting point: https://recreateyourrelationship.com/online-3-part-series-928281
- Book a free Breakthrough Session with Adam and Aston — get clarity on what is really driving the patterns in your relationship: https://recreateyourrelationship.com/breakthrough-session
- Attend a Recreate Your Relationship Retreat — experience a full day of breakthroughs and reconnection in person: https://savemymarriageschool.com/events/